Go to a couple of shops and shoot both. And shoot different models of each brand. Each bow will feel and shoot in your hand. I've shot Mathews for about the last 10 years. I bought a new one about 2 years ago and shot PSA, Hoyt and Mathews when I was shopping. I shot different models of each until I found the one that felt the best when shooting it.
I second the shoot different bows. I would also expand your brand search I shoot Martin and I love them. I don't search for the latest and greatest every year like some as long as the arrow hits the mark I am happy.