First I've used one, never felt it stuck out to far. Always ditched the clip when in a vehicle though as it didn't feel comfy. I've since switched to a belt holster. Also Are you dead set on a clip on? If not and ya don't mind belt loop check out 101 holsters. I carried one for a year in the stan and never had problems with it. The guy who makes them can custom tailor it how you want so before ya order shoot him a email about a light attachment and he can prolly model one up for ya. Life time warranty on parts and replacements. Two week money back gaurantee once it hits your door step. A lot of the spec ops are getting into them due to the durability and the comfy fit of the holster. With body armor, a chest rig for mags and a m4 I never had a problem with it sticking out when in vehciles or while walkin around and gettin **** caught on it. I still use the holster today for ccw and my wife grabs the side where my xd is all the time forgetting its there.Google 101 holsters it'll be a gone training website that pulls up with the info etc on em. If you need opinions go check out a website called socnet. Or google pics of em.