Everything seems to be cleared up. I was sent a new case (all LC brass) and a shipping label to return my old one. Now all I need is a chance to actually shoot some of it.
They sent me a new case still mixed casings. They didnt send me a return shipping label to send the old bullets back. I will try the new ammo he sent and see if I have any push-ins. They are really good people to deal with and I hope this ammo works out, I do like the specials they run as well.