So me tightening it to 50ft lbs and it having no play still isnt right?
If u tightened it to 50 f/p and your gas tube lines up then you are great. I have seen some up to 100+ f/p. The problem lies with the teeth of the barrel nut. I have tightened some and the tooth was just a wee bit past the gas tube passage and it means you have to go to the next tooth or try a shim.