For a fighting rifle I prefer a rail mounted fixed front sight (not standard FSB). My go to setup is Daniel Defense or Unity fixed front, folding rear, and a lower 1/3 cowitness red dot.
I've had even quality optics fail during classes. When that happens, you can actually do some decent shooting with just the front sight in the optic window, and flip the rear up when chance allows. What I don't want to do under stress is start piddling around near the muzzle trying to flip a sight up. A fixed front has a secondary benefit of helping aligning the red dot. Even though they are mostly point and shoot, if you start shooting farther or from unconventional shooting positions, keeping the dot/reticle centered in the optic starts becoming more important and a front sight post gives a good point of reference.
Why not a standard FSB?
Standard FSB is fine, I'm just not a fan of tiny handguards and non-free float barrels. A few years ago a pinned FSB was the only "rugged" option and low-profile gas blocks were gamer nonsense, but we are waaaaaaay past that now. Other than budget considerations, there is no benefit to a standard FSB/handguard setup.
which do you prefer and why on your defensive Carbine