Barneys
Rustyduck, I've been searching for gun shops with fair prices in Lafayette long and hard. I cannot come up with any. Even Academy is expensive. I usually buy my handguns from this forum, LA Sportsman, local classifieds, or Internet.
Buck Fins N Feathers is OK. Acadiana Outfitters has good deals sometimes. Academy is good when they have sales. Dave's, Lafayette Shooters, Barneys will rape your wallet. There are a couple of shops here in Opelousas that stock firearms but I haven't had a chance to look at their prices yet.
In Opelousas there is Advanced Hunting Systems and Saint Landry Lumber. Advanced just got their FFL. They have a decent selection of hunting rifles and a few handguns. Saint Landry Lumber has had theirs for a little while and has a pretty good selection of rifles. I'm not sure but I wanna say they had an ok selection of handguns as well. Its been a while since I've been to Saint Landry Lumber and like I said I never checked any prices. The customer services has always been awesome for me though. I've ordered several gun parts from them.
Oh, and Advanced Hunting Systems gives a 10% discount to all LEO, EMS, Fire, and military personnel on almost everything in the store.