Which would you choose and why?

[audioshooter]

As above. ^
Of course, if this were a half way decent hypothetical gun shop, they'd stock P30s also.

you forgot the 1911s

 

[Sin-ster]

150 rounds.. put 300+ in my old XD 45

Shoot it more. A lot more. It'll clean up pretty well and lose that grittiness you're probably experiencing.

EDIT to add: Dry fire will do the trick as well, although I suggest snap caps for sure. Even with the proper revision striker, I'm a bit squeemish without one in an M&P.

 

[machinedrummer]

10mm Nuff said

 

[mct601]

You *can't* go wrong here except in the ergo department. Everyone else said it right- shoot both (if possible) and see which one feels best to you. I shoot XDs, I do best with XDs. I can't hit **** with a Glock or M&P (which oddly is the best feeling handgun of the three), but when you break down the three pistols they are very very similar. Its minor things that separate the big three plastics, with ergonomics being the biggest thing. Out of YOUR two, I'd pick the M&P, but that doesn't mean its best for you.


sorry I had to beat the dead horse

 

[aherring1983]

Problem solved, just buy both

 

[kajun_at_work]

Problem solved, just buy both

Answer of the thread aherring1983!

 

[moliveria]

Problem solved, just buy both

That's what I did. In fact, I got all three brands. Got the G22 gen 3, M&P 40 FDE, XD40 OD, XD40 FDE (and 9mm conversion barrel). Plus other Glocks and M&P in 9mm. Waiting on my G19 Gen 4 from Barney's. I like them all!!

 

[ericlosh]

i like glock so ill recommend glock everyday, but really you should buy what feels best for you.

 

[RightTwist]

No StrikerFired Pistol for Me

Unless it's a ccw that you'd be using at very short range, give me a handgun with a hammer.

 

[Guate_shooter]

Unless it's a ccw that you'd be using at very short range, give me a handgun with a hammer.

Say what ....................

 

[SpeedRacer]

Unless it's a ccw that you'd be using at very short range, give me a handgun with a hammer.

I keep trying to make sense of this statement, but it just isn't happening.

 

[Bayoupiper]

I'd save my money and buy something I like.

.

 

[Sin-ster]

I keep trying to make sense of this statement, but it just isn't happening.

Agreed-- elaboration is in order.